Document Relay @required and export rules

Capture two conventions surfaced while building the top bar: use the
Relay @required directive to make expected-present nullable fields
non-null for consistent typing, and reserve default exports for the
component that lazy() imports as a bundle entry while everything else
uses named exports.

Signed-off-by: Émile Ré <emile@probo.com>
This commit is contained in:
Émile Ré
2026-06-26 21:55:14 +02:00
parent 68eaabe0ea
commit aa20bc4484
3 changed files with 122 additions and 0 deletions

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,45 @@
---
description: Named exports for components; default export only for lazy() bundle entries
globs: "**/*.tsx"
alwaysApply: false
---
# Named exports; `export default` only for lazy() entries
React components use **named exports**. `export default` is reserved as an
exception **only** for the component a router/`lazy()` imports as a bundle entry,
because `lazy(() => import("./X"))` resolves the module's default export.
In the Loader + Page/Layout pattern this means exactly **one** default export per
chain — the Loader (the `lazy()` target). The Page/Layout it renders is imported
**directly by the Loader**, not through `lazy()`, so it must be a named export.
```tsx
// GOOD — Loader is the lazy() entry → default export
// MainLayoutLoader.tsx
import { MainLayout, mainLayoutQuery } from "./MainLayout";
export default function MainLayoutLoader() { /* useQueryLoader → <MainLayout /> */ }
// GOOD — Layout/Page imported directly by the Loader → named export
// MainLayout.tsx
export const mainLayoutQuery = graphql`query MainLayoutQuery { ...TopBar_query }`;
export function MainLayout({ queryRef }: MainLayoutProps) { /* usePreloadedQuery */ }
// routes.tsx — only the Loader is referenced by lazy()
Component: lazy(() => import("#/pages/MainLayoutLoader")),
```
```tsx
// BAD — Page/Layout defaulted even though the Loader (not lazy) imports it
// MainLayout.tsx
export default function MainLayout(/* ... */) {}
// MainLayoutLoader.tsx
import MainLayout, { mainLayoutQuery } from "./MainLayout";
```
A page with no loader (no Relay data) that `lazy()` imports directly is itself
the bundle entry, so it keeps the `export default`. The rule is about *who
`lazy()` imports*, not about the "Page" vs "Layout" label.
See `contrib/claude/react-components.md` (File and export) and
`contrib/claude/app-arborescence.md`.

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
---
description: Use Relay @required to make expected-present nullable fields non-null
globs: "**/*.tsx"
alwaysApply: false
---
# Use `@required` for expected-present fields
GraphQL schemas mark many fields nullable defensively, but at a given call site
you usually **expect** a value. When a field is nullable in the schema but the
component cannot meaningfully render without it, annotate it with `@required` so
the **generated type is non-null**. This keeps typing consistent: callers stop
threading `?.` / `?? ""` / `!` through code that always expects data, and a
genuinely-missing value becomes a real signal instead of a silently-empty UI.
Choose the action by what should happen when the value is actually absent:
- `@required(action: THROW)` — the value is an invariant for this view (a page's
root entity, the `currentTrustCenter` a portal is built around). A null throws
on read and propagates to the nearest error boundary. Field becomes non-null.
- `@required(action: LOG)` — a missing value should degrade gracefully: the null
bubbles to the nearest `@required` ancestor (or nulls the fragment data) and
Relay logs it. Use when the surrounding UI can render a fallback.
- `@required(action: NONE)` — bubble nullability without logging; rarely needed.
```graphql
# GOOD — the view is built around this entity; THROW makes it non-null
currentTrustCenter @required(action: THROW) {
organization {
name # already String! — no @required needed
logo { downloadUrl } # legitimately optional — leave nullable
}
}
```
```tsx
// GOOD — non-null typing falls out of @required; no defensive chaining
const { organization } = data.currentTrustCenter;
const logoUrl = organization.logo?.downloadUrl ?? undefined; // logo stays optional
```
Do NOT use `@required` to silence nullability on fields that are *genuinely*
optional (avatar, logo, optional description) — those keep their nullable type
and get a real empty/fallback state. Do NOT use the `THROW` as control flow for
an expected-empty case (it is an error path, not a branch). Do NOT annotate
fields the schema already declares non-null (`String!`, `Organization!`).
See `contrib/claude/relay.md` (Fragments → Required fields).

View File

@@ -232,6 +232,35 @@ function ContactListItem(props: { contactKey: ContactListItem_contact$key }) {
Select `permission(action:)` fields (aliased `canUpdate` / `canDelete`) in the fragment of the component that renders the action, and gate the UI on the resulting boolean. See [`contrib/claude/permissions.md`](permissions.md).
### Required fields (`@required`)
GraphQL schemas mark many fields nullable defensively, but at a given call site you usually **expect** a value to be there. When a field is nullable in the schema but the component cannot meaningfully render without it, annotate it with `@required` so the **generated type is non-null**. This keeps typing honest and consistent: callers stop threading `?.` / `?? ""` / non-null `!` assertions through code that always expects data, and a genuinely-missing value surfaces as a real signal instead of silently rendering an empty UI.
Pick the action by what should happen when the value is actually absent at runtime:
- **`@required(action: THROW)`** — the value is an invariant for this view (e.g. a page's root entity, the `currentTrustCenter` a portal is built around). A null throws on read and propagates to the nearest error boundary (see [`error-handling.md`](error-handling.md)). The field becomes non-null in the type.
- **`@required(action: LOG)`** — a missing value should degrade gracefully rather than crash: the null **bubbles up** to the nearest `@required` ancestor (or makes the fragment/field data null), and Relay logs it. Use when the surrounding UI can render a sensible fallback.
- **`@required(action: NONE)`** — bubble nullability without logging; rarely needed.
```graphql
# Good — the view is built around this entity; THROW makes it non-null
currentTrustCenter @required(action: THROW) {
organization {
name # already String! in the schema — no @required needed
logo { downloadUrl } # legitimately optional — leave nullable
}
}
```
```tsx
// Good — non-null typing falls out of @required; no defensive chaining
const { organization } = data.currentTrustCenter;
const name = organization.name;
const logoUrl = organization.logo?.downloadUrl ?? undefined; // logo stays optional
```
Do **not** reach for `@required` to silence nullability on fields that are *genuinely* optional (an avatar, a logo, a description that may be empty). Those keep their nullable type and get a real empty/fallback state. Likewise, never select a field, mark it `@required(action: THROW)`, and rely on the throw as control flow for an expected-empty case — that is an error path, not a branch. And there is no need to annotate fields the schema already declares non-null (`String!`, `Organization!`).
### Refetchable fragments
For lists that support sorting and pagination, use `@refetchable` with `@argumentDefinitions`: